With the start of school just around the corner and with MANY a campaign out to combat obesity in schools, I thought I might share a few stats and facts. With gratitude to my colleague, Joanna Poppink, MFT, who graciously allowed me to re-post her article which was featured in the August issue of Case In Point (p. 33). While this article is intended for clinicians, I think that it could offer some important insights to teachers as well.
Obesity and Eating Disorders: Causes, Diagnoses, Treatment Options
by Joanna Poppink, MFT
If you take one thought from this article to apply to your work, let it be this: If you can relate to the unique person within the frame of obesity, you can know in your mind and heart that before you stands a human being worthy of respect, appreciation and caring. Such sensitivity and compassion equips you to be more effective as you relate to your patients, explore how obesity relates to eating disorders, recognize effective treatment options and access trustworthy resources for information, support and clinicians. I interviewed eight highly qualified eating disorder professionals on these issues and offer their perspective as well as my own.
Noneating Disorder Causes of Obesity
Obesity is a physical condition, not an illness or a character description. The causes are many and can relate to illnesses like Cushing’s disease or diabetes. It can be the result of emotional eating, poor eating habits, drug reactions, limited nutritional knowledge or yo-yo dieting. Several risk factors exist for both obesity and eating disorders, such as history of dieting, low self-esteem, trauma, childhood abuse, high media exposure, problems with affect regulation, body image dissatisfaction and weight-related teasing (Albers). Weight alone is not enough to make an accurate diagnosis or determine a treatment approach. Correct diagnosis made by a mental health professional or physician based on the DSM-IV TR is essential. If weight doesn’t define an eating disorder, what does?
Types of Eating Disorders
Eating disorders are serious illnesses that affect an individual’s body, mind and spirit. They have the highest mortality of any mental illness. No race, age, gender or socioeconomic status is exempt. The weight of a person with an eating disorder can fall within a normal range, be dangerously low or reach obese levels. Let’s explore some of the top disorders.
Anorexia: symptoms are primarily starvation, fear of food, obsession with body appearance and occasional ravaging binge/ purge episodes. Symptoms can reach emaciation, organ failure, loss of menses, loss of hair, dental problems and vulnerability to stroke and heart attack.
Bulimia: symptoms are primarily binge/ purge behaviors, i.e., vomiting and laxative use after uncontrollably eating massive amounts of food in a short time. The person can be underweight, normally weighted or overweight. Purging disrupts the endocrine and electrolyte systems and puts the person at risk for stroke and heart attack. Both involve an intense fear of gaining weight or becoming fat, regardless of their actual weight. Sufferers have a distorted body perception and determine their selfworth by their weight and appearance. They often deny the existence or seriousness of their disorder.
Binge eating disorder (BED) is similar to bulimia except without purging. The sufferer eats until painfully full and eats when not physically hungry. She often binges in secret.
Eating Disorders Not Otherwise Specified (EDNOS): A majority of people with eating disorders fall into this category. These are disorders that partially qualify for the above diagnoses. It’s helpful to understand the EDNOS classification because people can rationalize their behaviors, saying they don’t have an eating disorder because they don’t have all the symptoms of an anorexia, bulimia or BED diagnosis. All these eating disorders disrupt a person’s life, cause devastating emotional pain, damage bodies, undermine personal and professional relationships and limit a person’s ability to progress in educational or career pursuits. The sufferers are wracked with shame and self-disgust, which is often hidden from others.
Obesity and Eating Disorders
A person suffering from any eating disorder may or may not be obese. Their weight can range from emaciation to underweight, normal weight, overweight and obese. Obesity itself is not diagnostic. For example, an obese person can diet drastically or go through weight reduction surgery, like gastric bypass, live as an anorexic woman for months or even years, and return to an obese state. A person recovering from anorexia may gain weight that reaches obese proportions before her metabolism adjusts to a new way of eating.
Treatment Psychotherapeutic methods including EMDR (Shapiro) are effective when obesity is related to eating in order to feel safe and soothed. The obese person may need guidance and support in nutrition and exercise. A correct diagnosis is needed because putting a focus on nutrition and exercise, which can be helpful to non-ED patients, can exacerbate symptoms if a person has an eating disorder. Different levels of treatment exist to match the needs of the eating disorder patient, i.e., outpatient, intensive outpatient programs, partial hospitalization, residential and hospital programs. Finding the right match depends on correct diagnosis, the patient’s willingness to do recovery work, availability of therapeutic resources, and availability of adequate funding. Intense and comprehensive treatment often includes a team of professionals: psychotherapist who specializes in eating disorders; dietitian; physician; and psychiatrist. While this kind of treatment addresses the multidimensional aspects of the disorder, it also contributes to the high cost of treatment, all too often a barrier to recovery work. While cognitive behavioral psychotherapy has been the standard for treatment, it isn’t effective for everyone. I and other professionals in the field are on the constant lookout for promising new information, research and treatment methods that will help us help the people in our care. Fortunately, ongoing research and clinical exploration offers us more treatment options. Such options include: Mindfulness practices, EMDR, journal practices, guided imagery, art, dance and movement therapies, yoga, equine therapy, life skills teaching, stress management, attachment theory informed psychotherapy, psychodynamic oriented psychotherapy, internal family systems therapy (IFS), dialectical behavior therapy, and acceptance and commitment therapy. Leigh Cohn said, “The greatest advancements I see are related to diagnosing ED in males. The standard assessment tests were written for women, and men are often underscored on them. New tests are in development that use language that is sensitive to how males and females react differently to certain words. For example, the traditional phrase, ‘I think my thighs are too large,’ would more commonly be answered in the affirmative by women than men, who might react more forcefully to a phrase such as, ‘I check my body several times a day for fatness.’ The new assessments for men place a larger consideration on exercise, muscle dysmorphia, and on the terminology in discussing questions about body dissatisfaction and binge eating.” Each person who seeks treatment or is in treatment is in a particular stage of their eating disorder while also in a particular stage of their own human development. As they progress in both, levels of care and treatment methods change and adapt to the always current needs of the patient in the present. Regardless of the treatment methods, I’ve come to know that a sense of despair is a common thread running through the experience of a person with an eating disorder. To meet this despair the experienced clinician offers kindness, compassion and empathy as well as knowledge of the disorder and treatment methods. When a person is at home with harsh internal criticism and self attack, learning to recognize and respect kindness is a major element in recovery. Weight Loss as a Goal? All my colleagues interviewed for this article agree that reaching a healthy weight is the result of good self-care. Effective healing methods reinforce the individual’s ability to be present for who she truly is and what she needs to be whole and well. Then the emaciated person gains and the obese person loses. Losing weight is a side effect, not the goal of treatment My belief is that as a clinician I need to keep learning as much as I can about effective treatment methods so I can use them in my work with patients or establish solid referrals for treatments beyond my scope of practice. At the same time I try to forget it all when I am first with a new patient. I let the person lead me to the treatment approach that is best for them at the time. In this way the person can move gradually and with sense of security into the new territory of healing, a path that requires courage.
Author’s Note
Thank you to colleagues interviewed for this article: Susan Albers, PsyD, psychologist at the Cleveland Clinic and author Eating Mindfully, 50 Ways to Soothe Yourself. Web: www.eatingmindfully.com. Leigh Cohn, MAT, CEDS, publisher, Gurze Books, editor in chief, Eating Disorders: The Journal of Treatment and Prevention. Web: www.bulimia.com. Jean Fain, LICSW, MSW, Harvard Medical School-affiliated psychotherapist and the author of The Self-Compassion Diet. Web: www.jeanfain.com. Robyn Hussa, MFA, E-RYT, author, CEO of NORMAL, source of eating disorder educational materials. Web: www. robynhussa.com. Karen R. Koenig, LCSW, M.Ed, eating coach and author of What Every Therapist Needs To Know About Treating Eating and Weight Issues. Sarasota, Fla. Amy Pershing, LMSW, ACSW, clinical director, The Center for Eating Disorders, Ann Arbor, Mich. Web: www. center4ed.org. Dr. Nina Savelle-Rocklin, Psy.D., private practice, Sherman Oaks, Calif. Web: www.NSReatingdisorders.com. Francine Shapiro, Ph.D., senior research fellow at the Mental Research Institute in Palo Alto, Calif., director of the EMDR Institute, author www.emdr.com
Joanna Poppink, MFT, is a psychotherapist specializing in eating disorders, speaker, consultant and author of Healing Your Hungry Heart: Recovering From Your Eating Disorder. Member of AED, IAEDP. Contact: www.eatingdisorderrecovery.com | Joanna@poppink.com